Rhetorical synthesis on the SAT
You get notes and a goal. Most of the choices are true, and only one does the stated job.
How to solve rhetorical synthesis questions
- Read the goal in the question before the notes.
- Underline what the goal demands, such as a contrast or a specific audience.
- Choose the option that does that and nothing else.
Quick tip: Read the goal in the question first. Most choices are true, and only one does the stated job.
Worked example
• The axolotl is a salamander native to lakes near Mexico City.
• It can regrow lost limbs and even parts of its heart and brain.
• Scientists study axolotls to learn how humans might one day heal serious injuries.
• Wild axolotls are critically endangered.
The student wants to explain why scientists study axolotls. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- ABecause axolotls can regrow limbs and even parts of their hearts and brains, scientists study them to learn how humans might heal serious injuries.
- BThe axolotl is a salamander that lives in lakes near Mexico City.
- CScientists study many animals, including the critically endangered axolotl.
- DAxolotls, salamanders native to lakes near Mexico City, are critically endangered.
Show the answer
Answer: A · Because axolotls can regrow limbs and even parts of their hearts and brains, scientists study them to learn how humans might heal serious injuries.
- Read the goal first. Why scientists study axolotls.
- Find the notes that answer it. They regrow body parts, and scientists hope to learn about human healing.
- Pick the choice that does exactly that. Only the first choice gives both the ability and the reason.
- B. Background only, with no scientists and no reason.
- C. It mentions scientists but never gives the reason.
- D. True, but it doesn't say why scientists study them.
The common trap
The most detailed or impressive-sounding sentence is often wrong. If it misses a word in the goal, it fails.
• The Great Wall of China is about 13,000 miles long, including all its branches.
• Construction began in the 7th century BCE.
• It was built mainly to protect against invasions from the north.
The student wants to emphasize the purpose of the Great Wall. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- AStretching about 13,000 miles across its many branches, the Great Wall of China is an enormous structure.
- BConstruction on the Great Wall of China began in the 7th century BCE.
- CThe Great Wall of China, begun in the 7th century BCE, is about 13,000 miles long.
- DThe Great Wall of China was built mainly to protect against invasions from the north.
Show the answer
Answer: D · The Great Wall of China was built mainly to protect against invasions from the north.
The most detailed or impressive sentence is often wrong. If it misses the goal's key word (here, purpose), it fails.
- A. Impressive, but it's about size, not purpose.
- B. When it was started isn't why it was built.
- C. Two facts, and neither one is the purpose.
Remember
- Read the goal before the notes.
- Underline what the goal demands, such as a contrast, a purpose or an audience.
- Pick the choice that does exactly that, even if another sounds better.
Practice questions
Try each one, then open the answer to check your work.
• The Eiffel Tower opened in 1889.
• It was built for a world's fair in Paris.
• It stands about 330 meters tall.
The student wants to state when and why the Eiffel Tower was built. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- AThe Eiffel Tower, which stands about 330 meters tall, is located in Paris and remains one of the tallest structures in the city.
- BThe Eiffel Tower was built for a world's fair held in Paris and opened in 1889.
- CParis is home to a tower about 330 meters tall.
- DThe Eiffel Tower stands about 330 meters tall.
Show the answer
Answer: B · The Eiffel Tower was built for a world's fair held in Paris and opened in 1889.
The goal is when and why. This gives why (a world's fair) and when (1889).
- A. This adds height and location but leaves out the date and the reason.
- C. This gives height and location, not when or why.
- D. Height answers neither when nor why.
• The Library of Congress is the largest library in the world.
• It holds more than 170 million items.
• The British Library holds about 170 million items as well.
• The Library of Congress was founded in 1800.
The student wants to describe the Library of Congress's founding and its size today. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- AThe Library of Congress and the British Library each hold about 170 million items in their collections today.
- BThe largest library in the world, the Library of Congress, is located in the United States.
- CFounded in 1800, the Library of Congress now holds more than 170 million items.
- DThe British Library holds about 170 million items, which makes it a very large library.
Show the answer
Answer: C · Founded in 1800, the Library of Congress now holds more than 170 million items.
The goal is founding and size today. This gives both: 1800 and more than 170 million items.
- A. This compares sizes but leaves out the founding.
- B. This gives location but not founding or a size number.
- D. This is about the British Library.
• Town A added protected bike lanes in 2018.
• Bicycle commuting there rose by 40%.
• Town B added only painted lane markers in 2018.
• Bicycle commuting there rose by 5%.
The student wants to argue that protected lanes are more effective than painted markers. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
- ATown A and Town B both added bicycle infrastructure in 2018, and bicycle commuting rose in both towns during the years that followed.
- BTown A added protected bike lanes to its streets in 2018.
- CBoth towns made changes for bicycles in 2018.
- DBicycle commuting rose by 40% in the town that added protected lanes but by only 5% in the town that added painted markers.
Show the answer
Answer: D · Bicycle commuting rose by 40% in the town that added protected lanes but by only 5% in the town that added painted markers.
To argue protected lanes work better, compare the results: 40% versus only 5%.
- A. This says commuting rose in both but hides the big difference.
- B. This gives what Town A did but not the result.
- C. This says both towns changed something but not what worked better.