Cross-text connections on the SAT
Two short texts usually take related positions on one topic. The question asks how one author would respond to the other.
How to solve cross-text connections questions
- State the main claim of Text 1 in your own words.
- State the main claim of Text 2 in your own words.
- Decide whether they agree, disagree, or one qualifies the other.
Quick tip: State each author's position first, then ask how the second would answer the first.
Worked example
Text 2: A study of twelve cities found that new bike lanes did increase cycling. But most new cyclists had previously taken the bus, not driven, so car traffic barely changed.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the planners in Text 1?
- ABy agreeing that bike lanes reduce traffic because drivers switch to bikes
- BBy claiming that cities should remove bus routes
- CBy agreeing that bike lanes increase cycling but questioning whether they reduce car traffic
- DBy arguing that bike lanes actually reduce cycling
Show the answer
Answer: C · By agreeing that bike lanes increase cycling but questioning whether they reduce car traffic
- Text 1's claim. Bike lanes cut traffic because drivers switch to bikes.
- Text 2's claim. Cycling rose, but the new riders came from buses, so car traffic didn't drop.
- The relationship. Text 2 accepts part of the claim (more cycling) and disputes the rest (less traffic).
- A. Text 2 says car traffic barely changed, so it doesn't agree.
- B. Removing bus routes is never mentioned.
- D. The study found that cycling went up.
The common trap
Authors often agree on the facts and disagree about what they mean. Do not choose a response stronger than what the author actually says.
Text 2: In a trial, students who ate breakfast scored slightly higher on morning attention tests, but the difference was small and disappeared by midday.
How would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to Text 1?
- ABreakfast has no effect on focus at all.
- BBreakfast may help focus a little, but Text 1 overstates the effect.
- CText 1 is entirely correct.
- DStudents should eat breakfast at midday instead.
Show the answer
Answer: B · Breakfast may help focus a little, but Text 1 overstates the effect.
Don't pick a response stronger than what the author actually says. “Small and disappeared” supports a qualified answer.
- A. Too strong. The trial did find a small effect.
- C. Text 2 found a small effect that faded, not one that lasts all day.
- D. Text 2 never suggests changing when students eat.
Remember
- Say each text's main claim in your own words.
- Decide whether they agree, disagree or one qualifies the other.
- Don't choose a response stronger than the author's position.
Practice questions
Try each one, then open the answer to check your work.
Text 2: A study of elementary students found that more than an hour of homework a night did not raise test scores. For young children, short assignments seem to work best.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim in Text 1?
- ABy agreeing that every student should get an hour of homework each night
- BBy claiming that the study measured test scores rather than how much the children actually learned
- CBy arguing that homework has no effect on students of any age
- DBy suggesting that the amount of homework matters, especially for young students
Show the answer
Answer: D · By suggesting that the amount of homework matters, especially for young students
Text 2 doesn't reject homework. It says more than an hour didn't help young kids, so the amount matters.
- A. Text 2 says more than an hour didn't help.
- B. Text 2 doesn't criticize its own measure.
- C. Text 2 says short assignments seem to work.
Text 2: A survey of city gardens found that sites with hives had more fruit set than sites without them. Urban hives clearly benefit the local environment.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 1 most likely respond to the conclusion in Text 2?
- ABy noting that more fruit does not show that wild bee populations are unharmed
- BBy agreeing that hives help all pollinators equally
- CBy claiming that city gardens produce no fruit
- DBy arguing that surveys of gardens should include more hives
Show the answer
Answer: A · By noting that more fruit does not show that wild bee populations are unharmed
Pin down each author's position first. Text 1 worries about wild bees, and Text 2 measures only fruit. So Text 1 would say more fruit doesn't prove wild bees are unharmed.
- B. Text 1 says hives can harm wild bees, so it wouldn't agree they help all pollinators equally.
- C. Text 1 never denies the fruit result. It says the result misses the point.
- D. Text 1 worries about too many hives, so it wouldn't ask for more.
Text 2: Parish records from parts of England show that the ability to sign one's name was already growing before printed books were common in those areas, driven by commercial needs such as keeping accounts. Elaine Tsosie argues that a growing reading public may have encouraged printers to set up shop as much as printers created readers.
Which choice best describes how Text 2 relates to the claim made in Text 1?
- AText 2 narrows the claim in Text 1 by arguing that printing affected only those who kept commercial accounts.
- BText 2 suggests that the causal relationship proposed in Text 1 may run in the opposite direction as well.
- CText 2 confirms the relationship proposed in Text 1 by supplying evidence from a particular country.
- DText 2 rejects the idea that literacy rose at all in early modern Europe, which Text 1 takes for granted.
Show the answer
Answer: B · Text 2 suggests that the causal relationship proposed in Text 1 may run in the opposite direction as well.
Text 1 says presses created readers. Text 2 says readers may also have attracted presses, so the cause may run both ways.
- A. Text 2 doesn't limit printing's effect to account keepers.
- C. Text 2 challenges Text 1 more than it confirms it.
- D. Text 2 says literacy was growing.