Command of evidence on the SAT
Evidence questions give you a claim. You need the option that would actually prove that exact claim.
How to solve command of evidence questions
- Restate the claim in simple words.
- Ask what a finding would have to show to support it.
- For data, read the labels and match the numbers to the claim.
Quick tip: Restate the claim, then choose the option that would prove exactly that claim.
Worked example
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the botanist's claim?
- AOrchids grown in full sun produced more leaves than those grown in shade.
- BThe orchid is found in only a few forests in Madagascar.
- COrchids grown in partial shade produced twice as many flowers as those grown in full sun or full shade.
- DMany gardeners enjoy growing orchids in shaded rooms.
Show the answer
Answer: C · Orchids grown in partial shade produced twice as many flowers as those grown in full sun or full shade.
- Restate the claim. Partial shade is best.
- Ask what would prove it. A comparison where partial shade beats both full sun and full shade.
- Match. Only the first choice compares light levels and shows partial shade winning.
- A. This favors full sun, which would weaken the claim.
- B. Where it grows doesn't show which light level is best.
- D. Popularity isn't evidence about growth.
The common trap
Reading a graph correctly is not enough. A choice can state true data and still say nothing about the claim.
Which choice uses the data to most effectively support the teacher's claim?
- AA score of 85 was the highest in the class.
- BStudents who averaged 8 hours of sleep scored 85, while those who averaged 6 hours scored 78.
- COne group of students averaged 6 hours of sleep.
- DStudents who averaged 8 hours of sleep ate breakfast more often.
Show the answer
Answer: B · Students who averaged 8 hours of sleep scored 85, while those who averaged 6 hours scored 78.
A choice can state true data and still say nothing about the claim. It has to connect sleep to scores.
- A. The text never says that. It gives averages only.
- C. True, but there's no comparison and no scores.
- D. True, but breakfast has nothing to do with the claim about sleep.
Remember
- Restate the claim in simple words.
- Ask what a finding would have to show to prove it.
- True data isn't enough. It has to match the exact claim.
Practice questions
Try each one, then open the answer to check your work.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the librarian's belief?
- AThe library's staff has been asking for longer weekend hours for several years, and students signed a petition supporting them.
- BThe library added new carpeting last year.
- CMost of the library's books are nonfiction.
- DStudent visits on weekends doubled after the hours were extended.
Show the answer
Answer: D · Student visits on weekends doubled after the hours were extended.
The claim is more popular with students. Weekend student visits doubling shows that directly.
- A. Asking for longer hours isn't the same as visiting more.
- B. Carpet isn't about the weekend hours.
- C. The type of books isn't about popularity.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the nutritionist's argument?
- ATeachers recorded fewer attention problems in morning classes after the program began.
- BStudents who eat breakfast at home often arrive at school early.
- CThe breakfast program serves fruit and whole grains.
- DStudents who take part in the program say that they enjoy eating with their friends before morning classes begin each day.
Show the answer
Answer: A · Teachers recorded fewer attention problems in morning classes after the program began.
The claim is better concentration. Fewer attention problems in morning classes measures that directly.
- B. This is about home breakfast, not the program.
- C. The menu doesn't show any effect.
- D. Enjoying meals isn't concentration.
Which finding, if true, would most directly support the group's claim?
- ACorn prices rose during the years that the study took place.
- BFields with clover received half the nitrogen fertilizer of other fields and produced equal amounts of corn.
- CClover is a low-growing plant with small white or pink flowers.
- DFarmers who plant clover between rows of corn say that their fields look healthier and that the clover helps keep weeds from spreading.
Show the answer
Answer: B · Fields with clover received half the nitrogen fertilizer of other fields and produced equal amounts of corn.
The claim has two parts: less fertilizer and the same harvest. This shows half the fertilizer with equal corn.
- A. Corn prices are unrelated.
- C. What clover looks like isn't about fertilizer or harvest.
- D. Healthier looks and fewer weeds don't show less fertilizer with equal harvests.